Works / Article

西奴風與落花生：評史書美的「華語語系」概念

Sourced; not human-verified

Link to this record

Author 趙剛 Evidence ↗

Recorded first publication:2017-11

Topics: Sinophone Shu-mei Shih

Versions and publications

Traditional Chinese · Original

Link to this record

Sourced; not human-verified · Status inherited from parent record

Sources, verification and open questions

Status

Sourced; not human-verified

Source check date

2026-09-27

Source

External access
https://taiwanlit.org/essays/%E8%B7%A8%E6%99%82%E7%A9%BA%E7%B3%BE%E8%91%9B-%E8%8F%AF%E8%AA%9E%E8%AA%9E%E7%B3%BB%E7%A0%94%E7%A9%B6%E5%9C%A8%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E5%B0%8F%E5%8F%B2-2
Note
黃茂善〈跨時空糾葛：華語語系研究在台灣小史〉引注：趙剛，〈西奴風與落花生：評史書美的「華語語系」概念〉，《兩岸犇報》162（2017.11），頁 12–13

Open questions

原刊未见：2026-09-27 以题名检索网络无结果，出版项只有此一处引注，待核原刊

Full version details

id: zh
Language: zh
Writing system: Hant
Type: original

Publication overview

兩岸犇報 · 2017-11

兩岸犇報

2017-11 · 162 · Pages 12–13

Link to this record

Sourced; not human-verified · Status inherited from parent record

Sources, verification and open questions

Status

Sourced; not human-verified

Source check date

2026-09-27

Source

External access
https://taiwanlit.org/essays/%E8%B7%A8%E6%99%82%E7%A9%BA%E7%B3%BE%E8%91%9B-%E8%8F%AF%E8%AA%9E%E8%AA%9E%E7%B3%BB%E7%A0%94%E7%A9%B6%E5%9C%A8%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E5%B0%8F%E5%8F%B2-2
Note
黃茂善〈跨時空糾葛：華語語系研究在台灣小史〉引注：趙剛，〈西奴風與落花生：評史書美的「華語語系」概念〉，《兩岸犇報》162（2017.11），頁 12–13

Open questions

原刊未见：2026-09-27 以题名检索网络无结果，出版项只有此一处引注，待核原刊

Full version details

id

liangan-benbao-162

Published in

title: 兩岸犇報
issue: 162
Publication date: 2017-11
Pages: 12–13

Explore from this work

Critiques → 反離散：華語語系研究論 · zh

黃茂善综述将本文列为对《反離散》的回应，称其「針對離散及史書美對中國的閱讀挖苦」

Relation source ↗

Connections from other works

Only recorded relations are shown; arrows preserve their direction.

Discusses

「反離散」的前傳、挑戰／釁與其外

Discusses → 西奴風與落花生：評史書美的「華語語系」概念

Identification or relation unconfirmed

文中只说「趙剛與黃錦樹的文章」，未举题名。所指当为趙剛 2017 年 11 月这篇评史书美华语语系概念的文章：时间在本文之前，且是黃茂善综述所列趙剛唯一一篇，但本文未明言，故为推断

Relation evidence

Status: Proposed identification or relation; unconfirmed
Source: https://storystudio.tw/article/sobooks/sinophone-literature-review-1/

Sources, verification and open questions

Status

Sourced; not human-verified

Source check date

2026-09-27

Source

External access
https://storystudio.tw/article/sobooks/sinophone-literature-review-1/
Note
全文页：发布时间 2018-02-14，署名洛謀，栏目「說書」，标签「書評」
External access
https://podcasts.apple.com/hk/podcast/id1519667412?i=1000512873133
Note
《时差 in-betweenness》第 09 集 show notes：「Sham, D.「反離散」的前傳、挑戰／釁與其外」并附本文链接